Peppy Talks
Small changes, honestly assessed

Confidence

Being The Oldest Person In The Room

Experience becomes uncomfortable when the room is younger, because the assumptions attached to seniority cut both ways and the usual sources of assurance stop applying.

Two businessmen in suits discussing over coffee during a meeting in a café.
Two businessmen in suits discussing over coffee during a meeting in a café. · Photo via Pexels
Health information notice. General information — not a substitute for professional advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Being noticeably older than everyone else in a workplace produces a specific discomfort that is rarely discussed, because complaining about it sounds like complaining about having experience.

Experience is read as attachment to the old way

Long tenure is evidence of accumulated knowledge and is also read as evidence of investment in existing methods.

Both readings are available from the same fact, and which one a room applies depends on how the person behaves in their first few contributions.

The effect is that objections carry a different weight. The same reservation from a younger colleague reads as analysis and from an older one as resistance.

The reference points diverge

Assurance in a workplace comes partly from shared context: understanding the references, knowing the tools, recognizing what is being assumed.

In a much younger room, some of that context is not shared, and the gaps are noticed by the person on the wrong side of them.

The gaps are usually smaller than they feel. Discomfort about unfamiliar shorthand tends to be read by everyone else as ordinary variation rather than as anything notable.

Asking questions costs more

Seniority creates an expectation of already knowing, which raises the cost of admitting that something is unfamiliar.

The result is that older colleagues frequently ask fewer questions than junior ones, which is the opposite of what would help them.

Asking plainly generally resolves it. A question from an experienced person reads as directness far more often than as a deficiency, though it does not feel that way beforehand.

Not everything transfers, and some things do

Specific technical knowledge dates quickly and is the part most visible in a new environment.

Judgment about how organizations behave, which problems recur and what tends to go wrong dates much more slowly and is scarce in a young team.

The mistake is competing on the first and neglecting the second, which puts an experienced person into a contest they will lose while ignoring the one they would win.

Standing is rebuilt through contribution

Deference based on years does not transfer to a new setting, and expecting it produces friction with people who have no reason to extend it.

What does transfer is demonstrated usefulness, on the same terms as for anyone else in the room.

That is uncomfortable after a long career, and it is also the shortest route. A record established in the current room outweighs one that only exists as history.

helprequestscompetenceresearch
Priya Venkatesan
Work & Communication, Peppy Talks

Priya coaches senior teams through difficult conversations and reports that the hard part is almost never the words.

More from Priya →

Also by Priya Venkatesan

Confidence

Knowing what you are actually good at

Self-assessment is unreliable in known directions, and the corrections are external rather than introspective.

Priya Venkatesan··3 min read

Confidence

Self-compassion, without the softness

A construct with a reasonable evidence base and a name that puts people off, whose main finding is that self-criticism does not work.

Nadia Okonjo··3 min read

Goals & Motivation

Intrinsic interest, and where it comes from

The advice to follow your passion assumes interest precedes competence, and the evidence generally points the other way.

Nadia Okonjo··3 min read

Work & Career

Ambition, at a sustainable size

The costs of a demanding career are real and are frequently paid unconsciously, and the accounting is worth doing deliberately.

Sam Delacroix··3 min read

Work & Career

Reputation, and how it is actually built

It accumulates from unremarkable behaviour repeated, and the largest single component is whether people can predict you.

Priya Venkatesan··3 min read