Peppy Talks
Small changes, honestly assessed

Work & Career

Working For A Manager Who Is New

The arrival of a new manager resets how your work is assessed, because the incoming judgment is built from limited recent evidence rather than from your accumulated record.

Person in headphones walking in urban setting. Nighttime relaxation and music immersion.
Person in headphones walking in urban setting. Nighttime relaxation and music immersion. · Photo via Pexels
Health information notice. General information — not a substitute for professional advice. Read the full disclaimer.

A change of manager alters your position at work more than most other events, and it does so without anything about your performance changing. What changes is who is doing the reading and what they have to read.

The record does not transfer intact

A previous manager's understanding of you was built over years and lives largely in their head. Written reviews carry a fraction of it.

The incoming manager starts with those documents, a handover conversation and whatever they observe in the first months.

That is a thin basis, so early impressions carry disproportionate weight. The first quarter counts for more than the same period would have counted a year earlier.

A new manager is also being assessed

Someone stepping into a team has their own pressures: demonstrating that they have grasped the work, showing early progress, establishing that they are in charge.

Decisions in the first months are shaped by those pressures rather than by settled judgment about the team.

Understanding this makes the early period easier to read. Changes that feel personal are frequently a new manager solving a problem that has nothing to do with any individual.

Informal arrangements become invisible

Long-standing teams accumulate undocumented arrangements: flexible hours, an unusual division of work, allowances made for particular circumstances.

These exist as agreements with a person rather than with the organization, and they leave when that person does.

A new manager encountering them without context sees an anomaly. Explaining the reason early works better than waiting until it is questioned.

What the manager needs is orientation

The genuine problem a new manager has is not knowing how the work actually functions: what is fragile, who does what, which commitments exist.

Someone who supplies that becomes useful immediately, which is the fastest route to a favorable early reading.

It is also a legitimate contribution rather than positioning. The information is real and its absence is what makes the transition slow for everyone.

The relationship needs rebuilding, not resuming

Trust with a former manager does not carry over, and expecting it to is the common error. Latitude that was earned has to be earned again.

That is uncomfortable for long-tenured employees, who experience it as being treated as though the previous years did not happen.

From the new manager's position, they did not happen in any usable form. The reasonable response is to make the record visible rather than to assume it is known.

ambitionburnouttrade-offsvalues
Sam Delacroix
Habits & Behaviour, Peppy Talks

Sam writes about behaviour change and is deeply suspicious of any framework that fits on a single slide.

More from Sam →

Also by Sam Delacroix

Work & Career

Reputation, and how it is actually built

It accumulates from unremarkable behaviour repeated, and the largest single component is whether people can predict you.

Priya Venkatesan··3 min read

Work & Career

Being new at something in public

The discomfort of visible incompetence is what stops most people learning after about thirty, and it is largely a misreading of the audience.

Nadia Okonjo··3 min read

Work & Career

Remote and hybrid work, honestly

The arguments on both sides overstate, and the parts that are genuinely well established are narrower and more useful than either.

Priya Venkatesan··3 min read

Goals & Motivation

Why most goals should be smaller

Ambitious targets are motivating at the point of setting and are the main reason plans collapse in the second month.

Sam Delacroix··3 min read

Communication

Small talk, and what it is for

Widely dismissed as empty, and it performs a function that nothing else performs.

Nadia Okonjo··3 min read